Classic Butter-Basted New York Strip Steak with Garlic Herb Butter

There’s nothing quite like a perfectly cooked steak to elevate your dining experience, whether for a special occasion or simply to treat yourself after a long week. This recipe showcases the classic technique of butter basting, which creates an incredibly juicy, flavorful crust while maintaining a perfectly cooked interior. The combination of high-quality beef with aromatic herbs and garlic creates a restaurant-quality meal right in your own kitchen.

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

If you’re looking for exceptional new york cut steak recipes that will impress even the most discerning palate, this butter-basted method paired with a homemade compound butter delivers incredible results. The grilled new york strip alternative is popular, but this stovetop-to-oven method offers more control over the cooking process and creates an unbeatable flavor profile.

Ingredients List

For the Steak:
– 2 New York strip steaks (1½-inch thick, approximately 12-14 oz each)
– 2 tablespoons vegetable or grapeseed oil
– 4 tablespoons unsalted butter
– 6 garlic cloves, peeled and smashed
– 4 sprigs fresh thyme
– 2 sprigs fresh rosemary
– Coarse sea salt or kosher salt
– Freshly ground black pepper

For the Garlic Herb Butter:
– 8 tablespoons (1 stick) unsalted butter, softened
– 2 cloves garlic, finely minced
– 1 tablespoon fresh parsley, finely chopped
– 1 teaspoon fresh thyme leaves, finely chopped
– 1 teaspoon fresh rosemary, finely chopped
– ½ teaspoon lemon zest
– ¼ teaspoon sea salt
– ¼ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Prepare the steaks: Remove the steaks from the refrigerator 45-60 minutes before cooking to allow them to come to room temperature. This ensures even cooking. Pat the steaks completely dry with paper towels.

2. Season generously: Just before cooking, season both sides of the steaks liberally with coarse salt and freshly ground black pepper, pressing the seasonings into the meat.

3. Preheat your skillet: Place a cast-iron skillet over high heat until it’s very hot, approximately 5 minutes. Meanwhile, preheat your oven to 400°F (200°C).

4. Sear the steaks: Add the oil to the hot skillet (it should shimmer but not smoke). Carefully place the steaks in the pan and sear undisturbed for 3 minutes until a deep brown crust forms.

5. Flip and add aromatics: Turn the steaks over and add the butter, garlic cloves, thyme, and rosemary to the pan. When the butter has melted, tilt the pan slightly and use a spoon to continuously baste the steaks with the butter mixture for about 2 minutes.

6. Finish in the oven: Transfer the skillet to the preheated oven and cook for 4-6 minutes for medium-rare (internal temperature of 130-135°F) or 6-8 minutes for medium (135-145°F). While many new york cut steak recipes suggest only grilling, this combined method creates better flavor than a standard grilled new york strip technique.

7. Rest the steaks: Remove from the oven and transfer the steaks to a cutting board. Allow them to rest for 5-10 minutes, loosely tented with foil. This allows the juices to redistribute throughout the meat.

8. Make the compound butter: While the steaks are resting, combine all the garlic herb butter ingredients in a small bowl, mixing until thoroughly incorporated. You can shape the butter into a log using plastic wrap and refrigerate until ready to use.

9. Serve: Slice the steaks against the grain if desired or serve whole. Top with a generous pat of the garlic herb butter, which will melt beautifully over the hot steak.

Preparation & Cooking Time

– Preparation time: 15 minutes (plus 45-60 minutes for bringing steaks to room temperature)
– Cooking time: 15 minutes
– Resting time: 5-10 minutes
– Total time: 35-40 minutes (plus tempering time)
– Servings: 2-4 people (depending on appetite and sides)

Tips & Variations

Flavor Enhancements:
– Add a splash of cognac or red wine to the pan when basting for extra flavor
– Try blue cheese butter instead of herb butter for a more pungent flavor profile
– Drizzle aged balsamic vinegar or balsamic glaze over the finished steak
– Use a coffee rub for a unique flavor dimension

Ingredient Substitutions:
– Ribeye or filet mignon can be substituted for New York strip
– Dried herbs can replace fresh (use 1/3 the amount called for)
– Clarified butter or ghee can be used instead of butter for higher smoke point
– Use avocado oil for an even higher smoke point than vegetable oil

Cooking Method Variations:
– Grill: Heat grill to high (450-500°F), cook 3-4 minutes per side for medium-rare
– Sous vide: Cook at 129°F for 1-2 hours, then sear quickly in a hot pan
– Reverse sear: Cook in a 250°F oven until internal temperature reaches 120°F, then sear in a hot pan
– Air fryer: Preheat to 400°F, cook for approximately 8-10 minutes, turning halfway

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Not allowing the steak to come to room temperature: Cold steaks cook unevenly. Solution: Always take steaks out of the refrigerator 45-60 minutes before cooking.

2. Frequently flipping the steak: This prevents proper crust formation. Solution: Let the steak cook undisturbed until a good crust forms before flipping.

3. Under-seasoning: Many home cooks are too light with salt. Solution: Season generously, as a good portion of the salt falls off during cooking.

4. Cutting into the steak too soon: This causes juices to run out, resulting in a drier steak. Solution: Always rest steaks for at least 5 minutes before cutting.

5. Using the wrong pan: Thin pans heat unevenly and can’t retain enough heat. Solution: Use a heavy cast-iron skillet for the best heat retention and crust formation.

Storage & Reheating Tips

Storage:
– Refrigerate leftover steak in an airtight container for up to 3 days
– Store the garlic herb butter in the refrigerator for up to 1 week or freeze for up to 3 months
– For best quality, wrap cooled steaks tightly in plastic wrap before refrigerating to prevent them from drying out

Reheating:
– For best results, slice leftover steak thinly before reheating
– Gentle reheating methods preserve texture and flavor:
– Sous vide: 110°F for 20-30 minutes
– Oven: 250°F until warmed through (about 15 minutes)
– Stovetop: In a covered pan with a tablespoon of beef broth over low heat
– Avoid microwaving if possible, as it can make the meat tough

Conclusion

Mastering this butter-basted steak recipe gives you a reliable method for creating restaurant-quality meals at home with minimal ingredients but maximum flavor. The technique might seem intimidating at first, but once you’ve tried it, you’ll understand why butter basting has become the preferred method for many professional chefs and home cooks alike.

The richness from the butter combined with the aromatic herbs creates an unforgettable dining experience that’s worth mastering. Whether you’re exploring various new york cut steak recipes or comparing this method to a traditional grilled new york strip, this technique delivers exceptional results that will have your guests thinking you’ve been secretly training as a steakhouse chef.

FAQs

Q: How can I tell when my steak is done without cutting into it?
A: The most reliable method is using an instant-read thermometer. For medium-rare, look for 130-135°F; medium is 135-145°F. Alternatively, you can use the finger test: medium-rare feels like pressing the base of your thumb when touching your middle finger.

Q: Can I make this recipe if I don’t have a cast-iron skillet?
A: Yes, but results may vary. Use your heaviest oven-safe pan. If you don’t have an oven-safe pan, sear the steak and then transfer it to a preheated baking dish to finish in the oven.

Q: Is it